From: tabnak.ir
Subject: پاسخ دفتر آیت‌الله مکارم شیرازی به یک شبهه
Date: Sat, 04 Apr 2026 07:05:46 +0330
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/related;
	boundary="--419DA0BD5F2C447604121689AF08BA6B_MULTIPART_MIXED";
	type="text/html"
X-MimeOLE: Produced By IRANSAMANEH.COM

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

----419DA0BD5F2C447604121689AF08BA6B_MULTIPART_MIXED
Content-Type: text/html
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://mhtfile/index.html
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----419DA0BD5F2C447604121689AF08BA6B_MULTIPART_MIXED
Content-Type: image/vnd.microsoft.icon
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://mhtfile/favicon.ico

iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAADAAAAAwCAYAAABXAvmHAAALEUlEQVRoga2ae4xVxR3HPzPn3Lt3
d+8uj+VdKFiBSKWKrY9YUaHaLhqhKG3ERkODrcFHqbVpKEqqKdHUaitCUzWC+Gi1UbQhAWpNLE3K
asSYYAJVsIouj3Vx2WV32Xvv3nvOmf4x5zHn3HN3QZ3k5MydM/Ob7+83v9f8dgXff1cBoAAh9IME
4T/YICyQNggbpKUfYfnzgjWC025DLVGeBqVc3VcuKAc88+1iE6AXadSE3iQAGDCH9H9LY+zz8VDF
kArwSJ8JET3CxxPgUmDrzjA7hwIWxoCM3uYJBFNUjb75QyUFp+JrkCBUtEb5TITagnECNcUn4u/Y
huY3ESdRqx+JOeXUE7+F8oUr0r8jfAZS1WcIwkl0Af/BSQYYT0WlquapGvuLlD5IvSBt0edpygCl
fNJp9EU0lMrkqRuTPC18aXRVoq8MJkLd9ceDJ9D15Noko2lyTYzZpwy+VotpkyHZ2kYQAYlNCZhV
p3MAxgl8WVokiE4hQXfmBNh+l+DHc0X8BFRgrFSDj+Gq5kzbwJcE/upz4YEfCBpzhi8Umrgl4dnl
HldtuZfHzn+PFfNFgtnAZk4vmMgoWH0x8EvOF/x9wYesfv8PbF/pMnkUmIR/dbXgorbnEA88QG7B
Fayf9ga3fkcggkgePinEhxCwHG7CqbQJIwXrf1ghe8cK1KpVXLbuNnb+vMSM8Zr49HFw9/mdqFWr
wPOgsxN7yWIeOfNtbvy2iJ/CcM1zoPSZyUDCa6TSGIKwgl+0CiY+/2fUzp0azKZNnPnr5Wy73WFc
k2DdjyD/0FpEV1fktI8fp+7GpTwy71OmjRXR3qlOwGjFTs2E3yzOuvU+BOCWoHwCMnmivCNI6iw/
sTOSPP/7nKmSJy49SHb5MkSxGGUu+/bRMsLi3Jvm0Tr4DvLOO8FxzMwGTpygoTFDtvVKdrxLPNcJ
ufEf5cFgj5Z+3UiwsqCUYcSVXs3EaTQhYM0iScP990J3d7VbX7+e7408gly7ForFdCJbtzJ3ahmZ
jAsEjPjUBrug2KE3tRvCGVEu5BS0pFNTgHQVmj9LsmigDfXyy6mzVU8PPPoo7NgR85oxrI6DEhKV
jOIhrgEodIDTr08hkweR0Sm1ZkCAqugB5YFXAauuhiSi1lwv2LzMI3P9PVAu1569YYM23MR4mC4t
Xswbn9iowJCFH63LfVrq5T7AjVbVtcT20ifgDkYcFzugYRJYuSrQZrt5ns2UV/8CbW21J9XXQ2Mj
dHWlfhb5PIWbbmbtRk9fUNwSOH3aFr1ydKkJWnakxmUYsUTgT/bnuiU42Q6lY75NeKmbTx4tYO9e
lFJJc4ucycKFqB07UJMnB+LBUA7UDTfwSvdEOo58DH0H4ORBKHXFAEZIs5AbR1IbLGatuI9yH3iD
UTDBZ6TSpx+noJn0HF/VXPYddrjytiuYUPoMsWdPzLsIQNTVUdm4mQ2d0znnjiVkd7+J6OiIkuJp
0+h57GmWbTzO8RNFX1BmOmGKQkDjV7TnwcOSCikUyvOCQBboWErzXHALMNgNxU+hcBgGPuFI+0dc
87uD7PrZQ7BmDcqyYsvUypXscL/GXU9+zPWvZOj82zZUa6v+2NKC+9fn+eU/FPuPBOprSNbMpYSl
wduN4dD9S0dwyUxtp74bdUFBS3MWS0pqOB2feNQ53FXmu789yDOXrURt3Ai5nJbZokV88JNV3Pb4
YZRSbH+7l0sf7mbfuhfg4Yfxdu3i8Z7pPP36ceO+kLg3KLQzyU+DTHM4fPmsLHdelefQccdn+9o9
ikIH0hngnw/O5b5n99O2t1tLJAhgwq9MBI8MKhL6XpzNWKy/ZQq3lHYh9u/nwHU/ZeEfOzlwJB5X
RjfZXDmnifcOlXj/cImKU0NSQkDdKKgb46fouhIxtQVeW91MxoLpKw/huY7vhewmzhgLl3xjDFPH
t9O2N7wjGuIws8Ygy9TzyhWXO55o5+DiC6ifehG/v7udwmC18Xf3V3jxP921T1dYkB0BuTEgM9oL
KQ+BYsG5GR5f3sCUFsm6Hf14nsajGcg0Mve80eQyklH5TCKYpYCPHbkHQuA4Hg9u6agNrjZqHVmz
I7WqSJswdUBx1iT4zbX1LLkgQ8aCUkWx6V8nQ0h2QOTi2eMQQrB0/hQ2v3qIwmDSsE3J+x5Def4R
m+WO4QBLLV2rHuw8ZBr173Abl8YczJtlcfPlNgvPs7CtiOiWtwr893AlFGB4pZw9JYdSiktmj+bZ
1d9i5Z/2cfR4yZC4AVYHDKICVzBOPJuUtg77Vlb7cateG6awffsJZnqMahRcPMNiwTkWV8+xOWOs
pieECKN0b0Fx74u9qLBqp7BBYUnBjElR+nDd3Ilc8c3xvNR2gq1v9bDnoxLH+lwqjgEuqMxhZKxB
yVFmfKkGRa9oVX1W0NwAZ4yFmRMt5ky1uOBMi3O+apH3IZiglVIIIXA9xeoXejnYWcEsDgiu3aPG
5C0Ob/o6Wdu/IRlNKUV/SdHe5dDe5XLwmEtXv+JkSUtkYDAQul5nW5DLCPI5QUOdoLle0JIXjB8h
aWkSTBghaWmSNGSJqcZQTSnFUzsHWPFkN47r+l7JBTytQi3NNpZMJyaEBnH25Ayzp2RDyZhSCvpJ
5tOABHOUEayS42ZfKXjq9R5u39yP47iEtujbow2KuoyIFecCIuYmScBp40lgQzGS7CfXKaU4WfK4
55mPeey1fhzZROxygxfYgOBQV4Vi2SOfs2KgkhKt9TvJ0HBtuPkVR7F190nWPPMh+9t7dQotgsxU
heBDL9Qz4LLljV6WzR+VCqrWEScllgY0OT7UyfYVPba/U2DDtmPs3vcpnlPWDkLaRmodf+wgcVr9
XAcXzmhg1uTkZaYa4FBqkvQgwzF6sujxzkclXmrr55U3e+g41qOTxzBSNRILoEHN1e8LrmlT+o4p
mDAqwyPLJ7H4wmbfLr5gsSjRHFdRGPQ4cLTM7g+K/HtvgTf3D9DRNYBbHvDvH2YmKiE3PhYzCOuq
wS2vdbvCbtJRUUiEEJw9uY6ll47isrMbmTmpjjHNVk0vldZKZY9jvQ4dPQ7/6yjzyWcV9h8Z5IOj
ZQ4cHaSnv4znDOqboDdYnc4HW2VG6hMI0zKVSHFA0LrNH5Ug/UgpM4CFlJJ8zqKpQTI6bzOiQZLP
SerrpI4ZgKeg4ku2r+DR1efQV3TpK3gMll08z40uQuGlKHCHBthkGmLloG50YjACHjBjhxOUB+6A
r38AEg+LvqKk74TgiJE+VxEMI6NnvCNPMWRTKX1p6+ROiahCETAojL6ZC8WIBDqmvMSRpRRRVeId
GJlIKaSY47G+UROVWS15YRnzMEotcbp2XATCsPJqrBqoivKboJYfSspI9pRJIHHTMplThkjtPGSb
EiBNPILYH1CECupCScYSmWVVmuwPBEACJlKZTiq6KRxfGDLn3wUyPl1jbdITijgtO76pyYkx0SSS
8AJVYGMpd1JphXGCUhuq3ajVpgrcMF7PP8lIhZTxxVSJWmADFQklCTWZjhQcLP8yY+UI/jwRnbQy
+I2rSnzfSC42MufXhIKPhq8NQKUJeygBBeCFhf73hKx/qfHvCMnFQ9JKOQ0Dn01di/bRbiny0555
IVdxKSWphOX3AKz/PxXmrSue6qbTC1QrzUnE+iLW10YsbF31NY/StP6kpwrVJ+FWQ2BJV5sw3rCQ
m2QkxfMoYzypWrE4YG4cqkASmSGZWudepcOGV6lyz6LaZyS9nagajDUZbhIcTYyjGsZb5VITb1Nv
Yy4xZW4svzG+KUMAJpQw6uv+/wHqDR3MPycRhwAAAABJRU5ErkJggg==

----419DA0BD5F2C447604121689AF08BA6B_MULTIPART_MIXED--